Wednesday, July 18, 2007

Another Planet

I finished Another Planet by Elinor Burkett. It is another of the many books about education that have found their way into my hands. Thanks to fellow teacher Melanie for the loan. It is reporting on a year spent in an above-average American high school. There is good, and there is bad. In both groups of teachers and students there are those who work hard and those who just want to slide along. This is how Harper Collins presents the book:

In the wake of the disaster at Columbine, one question haunts America: What's going on in our suburban high schools? Award-winning journalist Elinor Burkett went back to school in suburban Minneapolis to find out. For nine months—from the opening pep rally through graduation—she attended classes, hung out with students, sat in on teacher gripe sessions, and interviewed both parents and administrators. With a novelist's eye, she takes readers behind closed doors, revealing a world of mixed messages, manufactured myths, and political hype. Another Planet offers an insider's view of the subculture of suburban teenagers, the plight of the nation's teachers, and the state of American education.

4 comments:

Sophia Varcados said...

What surprised you in the book? Did it confirm or shock or change you in any way? Are there better books that you know of that are similar? High School mystifies me...

Christine said...

It brought back memories of my own high school experience. I was neither shocked nor encouraged. Makes me wish there were more choices for high schoolers. Seems to me if you know early on that you're not going to college and that academics don't interest you, it would be better for you and your community to help you foster an interest in a trade or another vocation. I would like to see high school not be a place where we have to force people to be but a place where people choose to be, more like a community college. "Spinach is good! Therefore everyone must eat it!" No, no. There is also broccoli and beans and cauliflower and squash and peppers and. . .

Christine said...

Sophia, I wonder if Stephanie has heard of this book? The high school, Prior Lake High, is in a suburb of Minneapolis.

Anonymous said...

Hmmm...I will ask her. I meet many college students who I think would be happier in a trade. Really. Apprentice work seems like a great idea, or a combination of academics and technical training.