
That Padel is Charles Darwin’s great-great-granddaughter adds the allure of curiosity to her contribution to observance of his natal bicentenary. That’s good, because appreciative readers of this year’s celebratory batch of new biographies and new editions of Darwin’s writings stand to be keenly affected by this superbly crafted book. Rather than rewrite the letters, journals, and memoirs of her forebear and his associates, Padel pours them, as verbatim as rhythm and lineation allow, into unrhymed verses and stanzas most often resembling classical Latin couplets but also arrayed in repeating three-, four-, and five-line units and as faux blank verse. Padel’s own original writing fleshes out narration and description, though she is sparing with it, letting the native rhythms of the prose of well-educated yet nonliterary nineteenth-century upper-middle-class people envelop us with their intelligent passion. If she omits a few important episodes—most notably his experiences at Tierra del Fuego during the Beagle’s voyage—she definitely gives us a Darwin with whom we can wonder and feel, smile and weep. --Ray Olson
4 comments:
Interesting...I look forward to hearing your review of it.
I liked it. I learned about Darwin and his wife and family. He was very sick (with what they don't know), and two or three of his ten children died. Some of the poems brought me to tears. The poems are mostly words taken from his writings or other people's letters. Padel doesn't have to 'write' so much as she has to arrange, kind of like decorating a Christmas tree. But she has a good eye. I skim some poems until I find a hook that pulls me in, a line, a word, an unforgettable image. There were some of these, but not enough for me to call this a book of great poems. It's a book of great love, great family history, and maybe that's all it needs to be.
Hmmm...interesting. I think I'd probably rather get my Darwin from prose sources, though.
Also, the one book I read about him thought he was probably terribly sick with hypochondria, but that might be a tad cynical.
Just started a book about the whole Leno/Coco thing. Will report.
Post a Comment