Thursday, June 21, 2007

Your Turn Thursday

Great book/terrible movie.

8 comments:

Christine said...

Under the Tuscan Sun by Frances Mayes/Under the Tuscan Sun starring Diane Lane--Mayes sold the rights and let them play very loosely with the idea. Movie is nothing like the book.

A Prayer for Owen Meany/Simon Birch--Book has one of the best written characters ever. Movie does not.

Anonymous said...

Possession by A.S. Byatt is one of my favorite books, but the movie was very disappointing. Aaron Eckert was smarmy, and Gwyneth Paltrow made a strong, bitter character into a vulnerable lip biter. Yuck.

Allie said...

Memoirs of a Geisha by Arthur Golden is one of my favorite books. It stunned me the first time I read it. The movie - while visually pleasing didn't have the same impact.

Anonymous said...

Daniel says that the Eragon movie is nothing like the book. None of the characters are the way he knows them in the book. Much of the story line has been changed and he says certain events in the movie make it impossible for there to be a movie about the second book, Eldest. Both Emma and Daniel adore these books but Daniel has warned Emma not to watch the movie because it will spoil the book.

Anonymous said...

I think all movies made from books are awful. You don't want to get me started. DRD

Sophia Varcados said...

I keep raking my brain for a good example...DUNE was pretty bad - the first one released in the theatres, with Kyle whats-his-name.

Don said...

Apparently Christine will not blog again until I contribute, so here goes - Battlefield Earth. Yeah Ron's book was 400 pages too long, but the movie...Holy Geez!

Christine said...

Thank you, Don! We may now move forward.